Monday, May 14, 2018

Organizing Water


You can’t organize truth. That’s like trying to shape a pound of water in wrapping paper. ~Bruce Lee

I was having a discussion with a friend about a particular theological concept, one that has defied any sort of sensible explanation for centuries. We had read various scholars’ analyses; we had listened to podcasts interviewing well respected teachers and experts. I listened as my friend tried various approaches to understanding, until she finally threw up her hands in unhappy defeat.

Then she asked what I thought. Hmm....

I think that what I think doesn’t really matter. As Adyashanti says, we cannot think our way to truth. We are so wired to analyze, to categorize, to explain, and by so doing, to understand. Our sweet little brains just cannot stand to not know. It’s like a toothache that we keep probing with our tongue. Relief comes only when we have an answer, and we are so relieved to have one that we are loath to question it in case we find it lacking and have to start again.

But our answer is not truth. I can put water in a cup, but the water is not the cup. I can put truth into a belief or a concept or some sort of thinking structure, but truth is not that structure.

So is there a test for truth? Maybe...

Can you explain it? It’s not truth.

Can you describe it? It’s not truth.

Can you disagree with someone about it? It’s not truth.

Can you understand it? It’s definitely not truth.

The Sanskrit expression “neti, neti” meaning “not this, not this,” is a practice or meditation to reveal truth by identifying what is not truth. It is comparable to the via negativa or apophetic theology, which seeks to remove all blocks from direct experience of the divine.

We don’t find truth. We don’t need to find it because it was never lost. We live in truth the way a fish lives in water. Its eternal presence is revealed when we drop all the barriers we have put up with our beliefs.

If you can understand it, it’s not God. ~St. Augustine

15 comments:

  1. Hmm - I think you've nailed it with the last paragraph for me and of course those barriers can be so powerful and entrenched. I love the idea of truth being simple and not demanding analysing. A difficult topic!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, simple. One of my teachers answered my question "Does it have to be so complicated?" with a simple "No." When I asked him if we could talk about it more, he said, "There is no need. The answer is the same." Thanks for commenting, Lynne.

      Delete
  2. Your last line and St Augustine really hit it on the head. When I do my Wednesday Bible study posts, I always have to sit back after pounding the verse for a while and ask, "What do YOU want me to see?"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a good approach, CW. Adyashanti says, "Start with 'I don't know.' Why not just start where you'll end up anyway."

      Delete
  3. wow, those were some interesting thoughts on Truth. I did like the last paragraph.
    Here is a link to an article on "What is Truth". I think you will find some great thoughts there.
    https://www.lds.org/broadcasts/article/ces-devotionals/2013/01/what-is-truth?lang=eng
    Blessings and hugs!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Our limited minds will never grasp the entirety of the truth, so let's just sit back and, like the fish, be content to swim in the water God's provided us.
    Blessings, Galen!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I appreciate this so much. I catch myself striving to pin things down, to know the future, and really it's about trying to control outcomes. But, there is so much more joy in acceptance of where I am right now. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So glad this was timely. Someone recently pointed out that "striving" is clue that we are trying to control something or resist something. Striving blocks acceptance. Thanks for commenting.

      Delete
  6. "Our sweet little brains just cannot stand to not know..... Relief comes only when we have an answer, and we are so relieved to have one that we are loath to question it in case we find it lacking and have to start again."

    We seem to have a need for certainty . If we believe sometime to be true there is a real fear in questioning that, because if we do the whole "house of cards" may fall. I spent 35 years in one big belief system because it seemed to answer all my inquiry into "what is truth?". It took some courage to break free from all those assumptions. Now I have learned to be comfortable with uncertainty. Truth will set you free but not in a way most assume it will.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Your last sentence is so true Brian! Truth reveals itself as it will, not as we will. I can appreciate what you said about your own path, breaking free of long held beliefs. Truth cannot be contained. And indeed it does take courage to be open to truth without the safety of a prescribed belief structure.

      Delete
    2. Tao Te Ching- ch 38 (Stephen Mitchell version)

      I read this today....

      Therefore the master concerns himself/herself with the depths and not the surface,
      with the fruit and not the flower.
      He has no will of his own.
      He dwells in reality,
      and lets all illusions go

      Delete
  7. Yet another powerful post. Acceptance has been my friend, where resistance has not. As on example when I was first diagnosed with MS why me never entered my consciousness. The only possible answer was 'why not me'.
    Thank you.
    Sadly on lots of levels I still set myself to higher standards than I require of anyone else. Which is a form of arrogance I am trying to discard.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is an interesting perspective, EC, about how holding ourselves to a higher standard is a form of arrogance. I never thought about it like that. Along those same lines, I read that self improvement programs are a form of self abuse. Sort of the other side of the coin.

      Your reaction to your MS diagnosis is a model for all of us. Thank you.

      Delete

Your comment is valuable and valued. Comment moderation is enabled to block spam, so please excuse the delay until your comment appears on the blog.